Sunday, February 28, 2021

Drafting White In Kaldheim

 I win a lot with White in Kaldheim draft. I think a lot of people either don't do that, or they say something like "well White isn't as bad as Black, Boros Equipment is good" and show me decks with 8 Mountains, 8 Plains.

I don't think they quite get what I'm talking about. I'm drafting White.

Fortunately, I can use more words and images to try and tell people what I'm doing drafting White that they aren't.


The 3 White Decks of Kaldheim

There are three distinct White decks in Kaldheim: aggro, control, and Colossal Plow. All of these are trophy decks I posted to the Lords of Limited Discord a while back. (Listen to their podcast, listen to their Discord-Patreon-join spiel each episode because they say it better than I can)




Aggro is by far the most common, and the one I'm focusing on here. One-drops and equipment are the specific cards it wants that other White decks don't. Often these decks are playing 16 lands and solidly base White due their early drops wanting to all be White, so often 10+ Plains.

Ignore that Showdown of the Skalds and that Boros deck is still really good by the way. I'm willing to admit some of my success with White is having that card 4-5 times and never losing a match I have it or a game I cast it, but I'm winning doing the same things the rest of the deck is doing in similar drafts without Showdown.



A good White aggro draft will accidentally become Mono-White Pack 3 enough that you should keep an eye on your white card count later on, and that deck wants to play 15 lands. If you have a couple Goldvein Picks you can be "mono"-White with a 12-3 mana base and 2-3 premium splash spells too.

Boros and Selesnya are far better than the alternatives. Boros has decent bodies up the curve, Selesnya has bonkers gold cards and fine creatures, and both have good combat tricks. Orzhov has a weak base of Black commons that are often Black intensive, with Bloodsky Berserker the only real incentive for the aggro pairing. Azorius just has too much strategic tension to be true aggro, including taking snow lands cutting into the higher playable count White Aggro needs.

True White aggro is a deck you want to be drafting mostly uncontested because of the large number of White playables needed to support it. Another reason Boros is one of the better pairs for White aggro is you can fall back into a more split or Red-heavy deck without much effort. Selesnya can still carry if you get passed the multicolored cards and are fighting someone in Boros for the deck. Azorius is a fine fallback if you have non-aggro specific good white cards, but again you are falling back towards one of the other two White archetypes when this happens.


Colossal Plow is literally the namesake uncommon but you can fill a bit of the same role with Raider's Karve. You are assertive midrange, not one-drops (look at that sideboard!) and equipment aggro. Combat tricks remain good because Plow forces blocks, fliers remain good when you draw Ox without Plow, and Master Skald also becomes good. Your mana base tends to be more balanced, allowing you to draft the deck if White is contested but the Plow components aren't, and while I've trophied with Selesnya and Azorius lists I can see every color combo working here.



Control white is weird. The easy path is getting Doomskar, but the White removal is good enough especially if people start valuing Iron Verdict appropriately. I've seen this in Azorius and Orzhov (Orzhov usually has many gold cards, Azorius not so much), and I've had good experiences with Abzan Snow. This deck didn't trophy and was really early in the format, but it's an example of what you are aiming for. This deck is really fine with White being contested at a table, because the good White decks don't usually want many of the things you do and often end up committed to two colors, possibly allowing good multi-color goodies like Firja to slip through to your tri-color pile.

A quick tangent: my better snow decks are often solidly three colors. Too often snow has to take snow lands over solid playables, then gets dry later packs and is scrambling to cover the last couple slots. Being three colors minimizes the odds of dead mid-pack picks, and White works because Snow-Covered Plains often comes around late freeing up picks in subsequent packs.


The White Aggro Game Plan


Step 1: Ensure you get ahead early. When they foretell a card Turn 2 after a tapped land on Turn 1, you ideally made two plays to the battlefield that are already pushing damage through.


Step 2: Once they start committing things to combat your early advantage, have ways to keep making plays and maintaining the "I'm ahead" position you established early. Boast, moving equipment, combat tricks, some removal, just having flying creatures so their counter plays don't work.


Step 3: If Step 2 didn't deal lethal damage, have some way to crunch the last few points in.


(Edit/Aside: People have said a lot of things like "Equipment is good with fliers, tricks are better with ground stuff that will get blocks". That just isn't true here. A trick punches your fliers through their less plentiful fliers, and a lot of the tricks are Mammoth Growth or Run Amok scale things that convert fine to direct damage if your opponent isn't blocking and is racing your fliers.)

The White Aggro Pick Order


The general priority list for cards is:


  • Bombs
  • The best threats
  • Best removal, including best tricks
  • Good fliers
  • Good enhancements for fliers
  • Cheap creatures
  • Average stuff



Sam Black had a good segment a couple weeks back on his podcast (look for the Red White Aggro in Kaldheim one) about taking the best threats in aggro over good removal. I don't agree with him every set or some of his examples of premium threats, but in Kaldheim a cheap creature that contends with typical Foretell cards by itself is game breaking so in this set you should do that.



Even though I say take good removal highly, I have trimmed traditionally good removal spells from my White decks. You specifically want your kill spells to beat their Grizzled Outrider because tricks and Goldvein Picks don't do that, so my Boros decks maindeck Frost Bite less than half the time.


For stuff like Bound in Gold and Demon Bolt that does deal with big stuff, usually the debate about trimming copies starts around the 3rd one.

Issue 1: Whenever aggro gets bogged down in trading cards, the game tends to grind closer to parity where they have 5 drops and you don't. Same with when aggro drops too many removal, not enough threats to close. In Kaldheim, you want to use equipment to mitigate trading for small things, then removal for the big stuff. You still need to take removal highly because it's a more contested card type, but you want both.

Issue 2: Once you need equipment, you need lots of creatures, and from there your spell slots get limited. You can't play less than 14 creatures, and usually want 15-16 with 8-9 spells. Once Runes come into the equation sometimes you just end up cutting a third removal spell here.

So yea, sometimes you first pick Demon Bolt then end up trimming a Bound in Gold, but usually that's when your deck is a McDuck vault of good stuff and who cares about wasting picks.


High Tier Pick Order


Includes other top cards for reference. These cards are the reasons you move into White aggro early. Cards within a stack aren't in any particular order, just stuff that's generally close. The Battlefield Raptor and Vega tiers aren't actually quite in the high pick incentive stuff, but are there to give you an idea of what is right below that line.




Notes on non-obvious cards:


I don't have a great explanation on why Shepherd of the Cosmos is so great. I just don't lose when I cast despite it looking clunky, and it is always very clearly me winning because I cast it. Random two drops it returns have equipment to level up, Runes and Plows exist for larger advantages, 3/3 flying is a dominant sizing. It's the Voltron of Augury Raven and Sarulf's Packmate.


Runed Crown with any Naya-color Rune attached would just be a great equipment. You aren't trying to live a five Rune dream, you just want cantrip Vulshok Morningstar which you get from a Crown and one or two Runes in your deck. I don't tend to pair it with the Blue or Black Runes since they are lower impact additions. If a Rune of Speed or Rune of Might would be off color but I have a couple Treasure sources I would play anyways I'm OK with winging it, and a Shimmerdrift Vale helps, but I'm not trying to preemptively take weird duals to aggressively splash Runes. Tapped lands don't cast Battlefield Raptors.


Kaya's Onslaught is the Warp Pipe of the game phases I described. It compacts the "find lethal damage" Stage 3 into one combat and sometimes skips any effort of staying ahead in Stage 2 to do that. It on a 2/2 is effectives +4/+4 of damage, and it's too easy to scale even further.



I may have Battershield Warrior a bit high. In terms of how much a Boast keeps you ahead it's really high, but there's so many good enough three-drops it always ends up replacing. The 17lands.com data for the card is really bad but I always smash people with it, so my guess is also that as your deck strays from one-drop White aggro the card rapidly gets worse. For example I wouldn't want it over the Red common three-drops in a higher curve Boros deck that is trying to Axgard Cavalry a Craven Hulk.

Aside: If you haven't checked out 17lands.com for Arena draft data aggregation, you should do so. Not only is adding to the statistics pool for everyone great, having your own draft logs and results to scroll through is awesome.


Yes, I do take Colossal Plow that highly. No, you don't have to. The Plow decks can be a little finnicky.



Maja is similar to Trostani Discordant, which was Top 10 card in Guilds of Ravnica, and deserves a high billing. The rest of the gold cards underwhelm. Koll and Vega specifically require game scenarios to go right on top of drafting the cards, and Orzhov is just a conditional color pair and Firja suffers for it.

Note that with Vega I don't think Azorious Foretell is an all in strategy you should be trying to hit. It's just a nice Wind Drake that cantrips enough to be solid with the usual set of Azorius cards you build a deck out of. Also you aren't really trying to mix Auras with Koll, more equipment, but putting a Rune on something or making random Aura-based removal an even bigger joke comes up.



I might have the multicolor sacrifice lands a little bit low. The non-Boros ones are all generically super powerful, the Boros one is still good if a bit more conditional and slower, and if you have Shepherd of the Cosmos that's a nice little combo. White aggro's lower land count and heavy color bias make taking lands over solid playables less exciting, and I have found that they unfortunately aren't signals to end up in a specific color pair because people just pass them a lot.


White Aggro Playables Pick Order

The other way you end up in White aggro is if you see the top tier of these cards coming around later in a pack or wheeling. I don't have things within a specific pile ordered strongly, but in general take the mono-colored cards over the multicolor ones until you know that's your color pair.



Moving out of the single card incentives into the backbone filler, every creature that costs two or one is better than the more expensive ones. The only exception is Starnheim Courser because flying is great. Codespell Cleric is another card in the Battershield Warrior camp, where it gets real bad real fast once you drift away from low curve aggro but any deck with two Battlefield Raptor, two Codespell Cleric is well on the way to a trophy. Beskir Shieldmate tends to be the better two-drop than Story Seeker since you do a lot of work with a 1/1 body and equipment or stallking for fliers.

Almost nothing below the second tier is a default priority for me. The Wings of the Cosmos tier is all fine cards I'll play if I get them but are cuttable. The next tier down is sideboard cards and things I tend to cut, but Giant Ox and Master Skald have specific applications. 



Obviously Colossal Plow is good with both of these cards, but I sideboard in Giant Ox against Red and Gruul opponents when I have fliers. 


Master Skald is good once you get a couple Sagas in the three-color White control decks. I don't like taking Master Skald before I see the Sagas though, since most of the White non-rare Sagas aren't exciting and the off-color good ones are things you won't have many shots at. Also, don't put it in your deck because of Showdown of the Skalds, but do play it because of Firja's Retribution. The game should not need to continue to the second Showdown cast, but Retribution sometimes just dies to removal.  


Raider's Karve is also almost exclusively a Plow backup plan, since I don't want a lot of 3/2 or 3/3 for fours in my White decks.


Divine Gambit is more of a control card than an aggro card. Aggro cares too much about tempo to potentially waste two mana letting your opponent swap their five drop out for another five drop. It pairs best with another removal spell, since whatever scary thing they were dropping you were just going to kill anyways and you keep card and usually mana parity doing this.


Raven Wings looks much better than it plays every time I try it in White aggro. Just a lot of mana for what you want to only spend a little mana on. Not horrible, but try to keep them to your Sealed decks.



The two cards on the far right are there because they fall outside of what White aggro is doing. Doomskar Oracle is bad in aggro, and I'm not even sure it's good anywhere. It sits in the overloaded three drop slot, but just trades down. Iron Verdict is a solid card, but not in aggro. Once you are a controlling deck it plays like a high quality backbone card, but hopefully you are still getting them a bit later in the pack.



Don't play Valor of the Worthy, but try to draft decks that look like they want to. Then cut it every single time. It's not good, but the decks that look like they want it are great.


Gods' Hall Guardian trades horribly on rate against basically everything. If it sticks it's not embarrassing, but it sure isn't good and leads to a lot of rapidly lost games when it gets bounced or killed.



Warhorn Blast should probably be lower. I hate the card, it was bad even in a six one-drop deck with multiple Usher of the Fallen, it never does anything against me, and the 17lands data on it also agrees its terrible.



Funeral Longboat is the worst thing you can try to leverage random creatures with. If you somehow end a draft with no tricks, no equipment, and all dorks, I'm not even sure this is good enough to fix your issues.


White Rares


Notes on the ones that aren't just Angels or broken Sagas.



I didn't include Cosmos Elixer because the color White doesn't impact my picking of it, but it's a first pick windmill slam out of every pack it is in. Being White aggro doesn't even make it worse. The discount from Starnheim Courser is great, it makes racing with fliers easy, and forces people to attack you or die which is rarely profitable for them.

The other colorless cards of note: I haven't played with Maskwood Nexus in draft, but my Sealed experience leads me to believe it's fine but not a priority in White aggro. Tyrite Sanctum is probably at its worst in White, but if you have three legends it is actually pretty good and Changelings help you take the buyout of "technically Mistwalker is a God". Sanctum is more likely to be in my Plow decks than my Aggro decks for sure. Not in for Faceless Haven though, taking Snow lands isn't happening. Pyre of Heros remains not a playable card until someone proves me wrong.



Doomskar is my slam dunk path into White control. If you aren't comfortable drafting that deck, don't worry about it.



Righteous Valkyrie is mostly a 2/4 flying for three, which is good, but I've had it be phenomenal in Azorius with Mistwalker and Littjara Kinseekers as secret Angel Clerics.



Niko Aris is pretty bad for a planeswalker. The +1 does nothing, getting the -1 to kill a relevant thing is often tough, and the Shard token output is just paying mana for the right to pay more mana later to draw cards. It's still a high impact spell, but really slow and noticeably worse than Behold the Multiverse.


Rally the Ranks is a card I've seen be conditionally good in Boros, but I don't think the ceiling is much higher than Goldvein Pick or Tormentor's Helm.



Relevant Off Color Cards



I mostly end up in White because of White cards, not because other color cards point me to White. That said, being in White does change the values of certain cards in other colors by a fair amount.



Most of the red cards just kinda work with the White ones. Dwarven Hammer might be the exception and really lives up to the "best uncommon in the set" title I get it in Boros (and Rakdos, but that's not today's subject)> I mentioned cutting Frost Bite in many White aggro decks, Squash is obviously less exciting with a color that isn't Giants or Changelings, and Axgard Cavalry is downgraded to just a 2/2 status unless you are the split Boros deck with more Craven Hulks. 

Frenzied Raider and Fearless Liberator are both less exciting than they look. There's just a lot of win more in "I can attack with multiple creatures and spend mana on an on-board trick" or "my 2/1 is uncontested in combat" and a lot of potential for them to be Goblin Assailant and Goblin Piker. They are both cards I'm glad to include, but I think both are worse than Battlefield Raptor in many Boros decks.

Magda is pictured here because you should just be first picking that card. The floor of a two-drop that one shot ramps is great, and it just spirals out of control too easily even without really looking for other Dwarves. 

Don't play Reckless Crew. I had an opponent do all the things for it, cast it, and it ended up being Dwarven Reinforcements. The best case scenario it the card is a decent common.



Green shifts a lot since a lot of green cards don't work super well with White's not caring about snow. The reason to be Selesnya is usually Sarulf's Packmate or actual Selesnya cards. 

Horizon Seeker is really just a doofy 3/2 in non-control White decks. Any heavy Snow card is bad outside White Control. Elderleaf Mentor feels like it should be a Selesnya card, but you want your four-drops to do more and it's low quality filler.

On the flip side, Mammoth Growth is quite good in Selesnya Aggro or Plow. Same with Snakeskin Veil. King Harald's Revenge is kinda a low key reward for ending up in Selesnya. I'm unsure it's better than Mammoth Growth, but it's at least comparable and you get it last pick because Snow and bulky Gruul players pretend it doesn't exist. I don't even care too much about the pseudo-Searing Blaze aspect of it, I've been happy just giving a flying creature +4/+4 and bashing.

Oh, and Jaspera Sentinel is wonderful in Selesnya, probably taken just below Battlefield Raptor on that playables tier list one you know your color pair. It's not Loam Dryad, because Loam Dryad didn't pick up equipment and battle. Also that format had a lot less instances of Selesnya decks with piles of one- and two-drops but also a broken five-drop uncommon.

I have yet to Arachnoform anyone, but believe me I've come close. You can sideboard it in for mirrors if you want to replace a spell, I have lost to it granting reach.



There is just so much tension between Blue and White aggro. Blue is good support for White Control or the Plow deck, but aggro would require some weird set of exactly Augury Ravens and Berg Striders. Behold the Multiverse is not a super exciting aggro card, and neither is Mistwalker due to the heavy blue commitment to pump it.

I'm actually fine with Berg Strider in the White aggro decks at the high end. It's expensive, getting 3-4 snow lands is much more free than getting 6+, and Snow-Covered Plains is free enough. I again just haven't had the circumstances come up where I want to take Blue cards and mix them with White one-drops, and I really doubt I will.

Before you ask, the Blue creatures aren't good with the White creature enhancement stuff. It's just a horrible mix of clunky plays, creatures not needing the help, and drawing hands that don't do anything.

Again, the Plow and Control decks are fine with blue cards. Just don't mix Battlefield Raptor and Behold the Multiverse.



So... about Orzhov

Don't draft an Infernal Pet plus Codespell Cleric theme deck. It won't work. You will lose. It will be horrible.

I can imagine starting a draft with a couple Bloodsky Berserkers, then ending up in White aggro and splashing those, some Demonic Gifts, and maybe a Raise the Draugur or Village Rites. It's fun to imagine. In practice they are usually just bad versions of taking Boros cards instead.

Your Orzhov decks are probably more grindy Plow decks, maybe with Ascent of the Worthy once you already are trying to play Master Skald. Or they are solidly White Control, either heavy Black with Firja and some White removal and fliers, or the Abzan Snow Control stuff I showed off earlier.

Or you can tell yourself don't draft Orzhov and you wouldn't be too wrong.

Tuesday, January 26, 2021

Zendikar Rising Retrospective - Draft and Design

Party and Tribal


The core of Zendikar Rising draft was that it was a tribal set, and both the best and worst of the format was wrapped up in this.



It's easier to discuss this starting off with the good than the bad. I don't want to declare it unilaterally because I haven't run through the entire list, but Party might be the best tribal mechanic of all time.




I promise this tangent loops back: a few weeks ago there was a “rank every draft set ever” tier list going around. I had Ikoria somewhere between the top tier for fun and the required texts of Limited tier, and it's almost entirely because of companion. Even if that mechanic was a disaster for Constructed, it felt like the first time Wizards shoved all in on one of the things that makes Limited really fun: forcing dynamic draft picks.


The peaks of the Draft portion of Draft are when you feel smart for making unique decisions and when you get to maximize undervalued cards. This often has chain effects, because correctly taking some undervalued card over the default “right pick” means someone down the line gets paid off, and everyone leaves feeling good. Companion gave you a huge reward, and all you had to do was be the person taking the first jump in this chain of altered decisions. Not only did Companion give you more unique drafts to experience, it uniquely changed the text of of every draft it got involved in for everyone else involved and produced second-hand novelty.


Party does a lot of the same by creating consistent unique scenarios about which creature type you want. When you cross this with filling a curve there's a lot of potential priorities you could have in a draft, even if you learn the format and adjust for the roles that are naturally short staffed.



If anything, I think the biggest issue with Party was short changing this decision a bit. Each of the non-green colors had a primary and secondary creature type that were well populated, and one of the four types that was completely absent, but that tertiary type was literally a single low impact common. I'm not faulting the decision of making the one common low impact, since that means the person who wants that type gets it, I'm faulting not making a backup. Drafting a more Party-heavy deck outside of the “dedicated Party” pairs of Rakdos and Azorius meant you had one type with only that single common supporting it, ie. Farsight Adept was the only Wizard in Orzhov. That meant certain color pairs were horrendous at party because Highborn Vampire makes no sense in Dimir or whatever, forcing them into their linear tribal archetype (more on this in a second) and making them and the whole format just less deep and rich. 

The lesson?

If you make a good, lenticular (simple yet deep) mechanic, shove all in on it. There's a risk of homogenizing everything, but Azorius and Rakdos Party feeling so different (check out Sam Black's Drafting Archetypes podcast for good depth on this) implies you could make the full spread be unique enough to avoid this.




Then there were the linear tribal decks. This was the worst part of Zendikar Rising, but it was pretty close to being great. Instead of just counting each creature of the type, tribal was tied to a secondary theme: life gain, spell casting, mill, and equipment.


The worst tribal aspects of Zendikar Rising felt a lot like the worst of Ixalan, with Clerics and Wizards being the key offenders. I'm pretty sure these were the two best archetypes in the format, and they were largely drafting on rails. The biggest diversion from the default was when you first picked a Relic Amulet, then took so many good blue cards your Wizards deck didn't need red cards and could play your white or green rare instead. Congrats, you still spent most picks looking for blue Wizards or good instants and auto-picked the best one. Wizards directly did this via the “cast a Wizard” mechanic, but Clerics was more subtle. Kor Celebrant doesn't need a Cleric to trigger, but all the cards that also gain life are Clerics. Even if a random body could participate in the life gain chains, a Cleric did it better.


Maybe the game play was better than Ixalan, but getting to that point sure wasn't.


Relic Amulet is also a bit of an offensive card in a tribal format since it's so oppressive to opponents trying to control creatures, kinda like Sparksmith, but a single card miss at uncommon isn't a huge deal. Ikoria is an all-timer despite Zenith Flare.




Rogues and Warriors were a little closer to interesting, and it was because they were less supported. Warriors is probably the better example, as no one ever had a good answer for what a good Rogues deck without Soaring Thought-Thief or Zareth San looked like.


Warriors was about ending up with high power attackers, but that tied into the equipment subtheme. Cliffhaven Kitesail ended up being a key piece to tie everything together, and you wanted that in a specific quantity, but in the end that could go on any high power creature just as well as a Warrior. There were a few specific cards that paid you for having a lot of Warriors, but mostly it was just a matter of having enough to make Expedition Champion hit them hard. 


The single-other-Warrior nature of that payoff was great and gave the deck room to play non-Warriors at lower cost. In another cool twist, otherwise high priority Party cards like Grotag Bug-Catcher went down in value because they were Warriors, and all your other Warriors meant their Party floor was closer to 1 member than the usual 2 members for controlling any other creature.




And guess what? These soft, conditional tribal strategies have been the ones that lead to the best formats. All of the Innistrad sets have approached tribal this way, and every time it's been a slam dunk implementation. The secondary mechanic focus of each tribe is another great way to maximize this. You can mesh in other cards that incidentally work well with equipment or life gain.


Zendikar Rising went too far on the raw tribal pieces here. It was a combination of “every Cleric has to do the Cleric thing” and just the raw power of the top payoffs, but in the end those overpowered the Party setups the format really should have been about.


Makindi Ox, or Makindi GOAT?




Makindi Ox was among my favorite commons in Zendikar Rising. It wasn't the best card, and I wasn't taking it highly, but I won some massive percentage of the games I resolved the card. And it wasn't just Makindi Ox. Dreadwurm, Living Tempest, Spitfire Lagac were all fine for the same reasons.


The lesson is up front this time: if your filler commons aren't going to be synergistic, at least make enough of them impactful when drawn and cast.


Like I said before, the key to good draft formats is giving people things to do with the cards that wheel. In the actual best sets of all time, that usually involves crazy intermeshed synergies with that common, often with specific build arounds. Think about Runic Repetition in the Spider Spawning deck being unplayable anywhere else. Or it involves something like cycling letting you mesh a free roll onto a conditional but fine playable, which was basically the entire story of Hour of Devastation draft.


Zendikar Rising chose a third path because it was a broadly linear tribal set without a cycling-style mechanic: make the lower individual impact cards the high priority synergy cards, then make a lot of the non-synergy cards just decent, high impact stuff.



Looking at past sets, I think this was the biggest reason Throne of Eldraine missed for me. There wasn't really room for this kind of design because a lot of the thematic payoffs were those higher cost, high impact cards, and the ends of the packs were real stinkers that didn't do anything when drawn. Some of this is the Adamant mechanic naturally pushing the mono-color payoffs into the five-drop slot, but if that's a mechanic in the set it may have been worth considering a different path to make later picks matter.


You don't need every filler card to be a high impact card like this, and you don't need all your high drops to be non-synergy pieces like this. There's still Guul Draz Mucklord in this set. You just need enough that people reliably get a couple cards that matter when you draw them on the wheel, so that their drafts that don't go to plan feel like they are competing in games.




Also shout out to the concept of giving white four power creatures at common. Makindi Ox is the 7th one of those ever, and three have been since Theros Beyond Death and one was New Phyrexia making a mockery of that paradigm with a 4/2 for four. So many of white's Draft struggles in 2019 can be summed up by "their cards aren't impactful" and this helps a lot more than it looks like it would.


The Green Rant



Why isolate green with weird archetypes when you can bridge those with party when green is the all types color? I get giving the flex color worse Party payoffs, but why is there only one and it is so bad? Why not make dual-class creatures in green to actually give it a reason to Party?




Why are there no landfall creatures with a Party type? Why are there more Party typed creatures that get +1/+1 counters in white than in green? Why are as many kicker plus Party type creatures in red as there are in green, and twice as many in blue? Why repeat the Battle for Zendikar issue of making green basically four colors of cards that don't overlap in a single color? Especially when Party is in the set, so random creature with text can be playable because of types even if the synergy doesn't hit.


Hitting people with 6/5s is nice, but a functional color that you can move into in draft without throwing out seven earlier picks is better.


Good Odds and Acceptable Ends




The rares in Zendikar Rising were really, really nice for Limited. The crushing non-creatures were setup dependent or tempo negative. The bomby creatures gave you a window to kill them at parity. Luminarch Aspirant was kinda messed up, but that's about it.

You can print game dominating rares and still have a good set. Just don't make them lifelink indestructible hexproof cantrips that immediately Wrath your opponent (Theros Beyond Death) and you are off to a good start.



I have no issues with Golgari Counters failing. Sometimes an archetype doesn't work. Again, the failure was not giving the color pair a default, acceptable backup plan in Party, or maybe it was just splitting the non-synergy black cards from the green ones using that Party vs lone non-Party color wedge.



The modal DFC lands were just flawless for Limited. I really don't know if another run of them can match how perfectly selected these effects were. They were unique but simple, always a decision, not dominating or warping, but helped out in a very visible and concrete way every time in either direction.

I just want to repeat that compliment: these were so well designed, doing them again needs to be handled with caution to not underdeliver the high expectations.



Landfall was also really well done. The lessons from the last times was taken to heart: Steppe Lynx looks way more exciting/enticing than Scythe Leopard, but you need to be careful aggressive landfall doesn't negate blocking. This set hit a good balance of rehashing the old (Lotus Cobra, Akoum Hellhound), avoiding those pitfalls (Brushfire Elemental as gold uncommon Plated Geopede), and bringing new things to the table (Felidar Retreat, Makindi Ox). Add in how it meshed with the DFCs and you have another success story.


Where Was The Zendikar in Zendikar?


But the real miss that goes beyond draft? This wasn't Zendikar. It said Landfall, it tried to replace Allies, it has Zendikar names, but it's in the uncanny valley.




Zendikar had two parts: Dungeons and Dragons, and Indiana Jones. It was groups and individuals questing for treasure and discovery, but the world was unstable, filled with traps and land that would rise up and do stuff.


This set got as far as groups questing, but stopped. There wasn't even a purpose of finding treasure, discovering things (the quest enchantments) let alone traps or peril. Where did all that go?


Weirdly, if the problem with draft was the party mechanic wasn't saturated enough, the creative issue was that it was all consuming.



Even if you are trying to distance from the Eldrazi era of Zendikar, you have material to draw from. The world had spots drained to dust, had fractures in reality. Those are new kinds of peril and traps left behind without a single noodly, hedron crowned, or quad-armed thing from beyond


Maybe the quest isn't treasure, but just rebuilding something to live in. Not that original Zendikar showed a world with a lot of civilization, but there's still purpose and not just durdling Clerics and Rogues.




Mechanically, why are there actual zero allusions to quests or traps, but they could fit in a converge card? I actually had to work to remember the name of that mechanic because it's just sunburst and was utterly forgettable in Battle for Zendikar.

This all sounds like nitpicks, but it isn't. The point of returning to a creative asset is making a cohesive and deeper world. Dominaria may have been a bit on the fan service side of things, but it told a story while recognizing and building on what existed. Scars of Mirrodin was basically an entirely different slant than the original Mirrodin, but it tried hard to capture so much of the original style and mechanics for the Mirrodin pieces. Shadows over Innistrad was so faithful to expanding the source material that it may as well have been the third set replacing Avacyn Restored.



Zendikar Rising just takes the brand name and slaps it on a sticker. Doing landfall well and nothing else almost makes it worse, like that mechanic is the only relevant history here. 

Maybe some of this was compounded by Zendikar Rising sitting in the Constructed shadows of Throne of Eldraine, and that looming presence is why I skipped discussing the set in Constructed. Maybe if it had the chance to be the star of the show it could build it's own identity, but I can't help but feel like if the set had the right permeating flavor of a return it couldn't overcome that.

So much of what I say about Zendikar Rising sounds harsh, and I really try to temper that because so much of the set was really well done. Party, MDFCs, the balance of 279 of the 280 cards. But a key thing repeated in Magic design is “it is better for a set to have people who love it and hate it than be a set that's just fine”, and Zendikar Rising missed there. Time and time again, it failed to really push on its principles and produced the minimum viable version of the best things it did. When inevitably one or two margin shots missed in the set, it becomes easier to criticize those than to say deep statements about what is good, because all the nuance is in why something failed and not crafting the successes.



Sunday, September 27, 2020

What Broke Standard?

Since Throne of Eldraine, Standard has been a mess outside of, well, the Theros Beyond Death format that was a mess of messes. 


This is despite an entire new department, Play Design, being spun up at Wizards of the Coast just before that point to test Standard and optimize the format due to the last batch of disasters. What the hell went wrong? Was it mistakes in testing? Was it the world drastically changing? How did we get into this mess so people can even think of ways to get out of it.


Don't Blame the Data





Five years ago, we had data as good as today if not better. Magic Online used to let third parties watch every replay of every match played, with four-round Daily Events happening multiple times a day for each format, similar in scope to the current five-round Preliminaries or SCGTour Online Challenges. There were also larger Premier events, two-player queues firing regularly, and all of this data turn-by-turn could be logged by a bot. You could pull up a grid and have a three- or four-digit sample size telling you who was ahead in every Modern matchups. If you had the raw data set you could even correlate who won more when specific cards were cast, or cast by specific turns, or when a sideboard card was involved. If you wanted Limited content, MTG Goldfish scraped the draft queues to see what cards had the highest win rates when cast!

Even if you didn't like raw numbers because you could move them with deck building decisions, you get every 4-0 or 3-1 deck from every one of those Daily events. Sounds similar to the data set we have these days?

Standard didn't break. Modern didn't break.

We didn't have anything close to this data set last year when Field of the Dead and Oko, Thief of Crowns broke everything.

When Temur Reclamation was crushing, I kept a close eye on the mtgmeta.io data set. It kept saying things were bad matchups when I knew how to win them, and the best players kept winning with Temur Reclamation against the field.

I'm not saying people don't look at the data and it doesn't influence decisions, but maybe it's not the data breaking Standard.


Don't Blame the Tech



Twitter has existed for 10 years and it didn't break Standard. Discord is a well polished version of a 2005-era moderated forum, which honestly is one of the greater mediums in Internet history so I have no issues moving back to it. Things aren't that different from Standard's working days.

The one thing that may have changed is the monetization incentives of Twitch. It is likely someone else has a similar idea to you, and it's likely you can accelerate your ideas by watching their game play at double-speed. That's because when they have a good idea, they get viewers, and that pays real dollars (or as the Pro Tour documents for American venues loved to say, sometimes called “greenbacks”) and not just internet clout. Just kidding, I've seen some numbers for smaller streamers and it does pay in amounts that round to clout, but you know maybe you through enough clout farming you become a big timer and make medium or decent money some day.

But uhh, ask Cedric about The Stream Team one day, and that Pro Tour where he rolled up with Jund and played Geralf's Messenger instead of Deathrite Shaman. Streamer data is a starting point, but not the finish line. Twitch is also almost a decade old, even if it wasn't as populated by Magic content before Arena.

Tech changes might have an impact on metagame churn, but I don't think that tells the story at all.


Threat Design


This is really obvious, and there's no better place to point to this than Uro and Omnath.


What don't these cards do? They draw cards, provide life total buffers, provide mana, one of them even casts itself from the graveyard, and whatever they do they keep doing it. Oko, Thief of Crowns existed in a similar space of life gain, permanent value generation, threatening to blank threats, and just raw speed.


 

Back in the day you had to invest in a different threat for a different job. To use and expand on the classic Patrick Chapin role assignments, you had Baneslayer Angels that could rectify game states but died to removal, Mulldrifters that were raw card advantage at the cost of smaller immediate impact, Morphlings that were unkillable and closed the game at cost. Dark Confidants (or Ophidians or Thieving Magpies for the ancients) didn't provide defensive or offensive strength but threatened to accumulate value if given time unanswered. Depending on whether you expected more aggro, midrange, or control in the metagame the optimal choice changed.

Where is the choice these days? Uro just beats aggro, control, and midrange. So does Omnath. So did Oko.

When you don't have to make real choices, you get homogenization. You don't have to choose the scale your deck operates at, you have tools to cover everything.

That's a problem.


Answer Design


We learned the lesson in years past that removal that is too efficient, too broad make it so the cards in the format don't matter much outside of doing something and costing little enough to avoid trading poorly for the answers. My hot take is maybe we deserve Mana Leak and maybe Pioneer and Historic need it, but it certainly would have baggage. Again, the theme of decisions mattering or not mattering shows up.


Answers haven't been quite as bad as people think they were, Temur Reclamation was basically an all answers deck with some good mana and card advantage. But they got really bad after rotation. You can kill basically any creature pretty easily, but as we mentioned the good creatures don't die or cantrip and it's all horrible. Planeswalkers are pretty hard to kill, especially when they are the Theros Beyond Death or Thone of Eldraine ones printed under the War of the Spark era's absurd numbers. The only good way to kill things right now is Bonecrusher Giant, Mystical Dispute, Spikefield Hazard, as evidenced by all the four-color decks deciding none of the other answers are good enough to reliably play.


This might be temporary and answers could come back once were aren't forced to exclude black mana from our decks.

I think the biggest problem might have been what I alluded to with Temur Reclamation. We've entered a world where the best answers often are best utilized in a deck maximizing the best threats. There's an entire extra blog post about this, especially with how it related to Aether Gust being a problem and Mystical Dispute being great, but this all points back to the threats making mana and drawing cards and doing that over and over. If you keep getting cards and mana, the best thing to do is stop your opponent from doing the same thing so that your cards and mana kill them because they don't have cards and mana.

Answer design probably isn't a major issue, but it's a bit weak right now. Whatever, that happens in small Standard, cards like Carnage Tyrant have often dominated formats because there were only like two answers that existed for them before.


Closing the Ramp Gap


 

Growth Spiral was banned in Standard. Explore wasn't. Lotus Cobra when it was printed the first time was powerful, but not broken like this despite having Misty Rainforest in the format


The things you would Explore or Lotus Cobra into those days often cost six or seven, Primeval Titan or Avenger of Zendikar. These days, they cost four, Wilderness Reclamation or Omnath.

When you look at the answers, this is troublesome. A successful strategy against ramp used to be getting out under them and efficiently stopping their payoff. There isn't really an under them when their best hands deploy that threat after you have only had two turns to play. You can't leave up Disdainful Stroke on the draw after playing a one-drop and expect to win. That extra turn or two of setup gives you time to produce enough things to really punish them even if you only buy a single turn against their threat, thing of how the various Pioneer and Modern Spirits decks hit a specific point where they deal much larger amounts of damage because they set up Lords.

The raw number of cards between four and six also matters. When you need six lands to produce a Primeval Titan, that's six actual cards you need at specific points. The old ramp decks often stumbled, and stumbled more in the games where they drew interaction. Think of how Modern Valakut Titan decks operated before they got squeezed out of the metagame, or the Scapeshift quote I've said for years “Scapeshift is a one-card combo that takes eight or nine cards to win the game”.


Ok, Explore into Jace, the Mind Sculptor was pretty dumb. But Jace was uniquely vulnerable to small-ball creature setups and Bloodbraid Elf, so it kinda worked out. Bloodbraid Elf off Explore was also kinda dumb, but that card played pretty bad with Explore left in your deck and often was better a turn later when the cascade hit something reactive against their later must answer play. Not quite the same as Wilderness Reclamation which is just good and hard to answer whenever it hits.


Like, have you read Grave Titan? Aggro decks could race that card despite what it does.

Yet again the problem lies with the threats, but it's not just the text boxes but the costs.


London Mulligan.... and Open Decklists


I had some lightly tested, lightlyspeculative concerns about the London Mulligan a year and a half ago after testing for the namesake Mythic Championship in London itdebuted at. It's been bad in those ways, but somehow it may be worse in a different way that is definitely a big part of ruining Standard.

There just isn't a reason to play a linear strategy, because even pre-sideboarding your opponent can significantly adjust to preempt your plans.

Before the combination of open decklists and the London Mulligan, midrange decks had a huge issue playing against the field. You would have some Doom Blades in your deck and some Duresses, and you would start each game down a Schroedinger's Cat of a draw when you drew Doom Blades against control and when you drew your Duresses against aggro. When your opponent played their first turn, you would learn how bad your decision was or wasn't.

These days, you can peek in the box. If the cat is dead and you have Duress against aggro, you can trade it in for a new box. Unlike before, if you draw a Duress in that next hand it doesn't have to stay there and you can keep the six cards that do matter. You play way more games with a piece or two of interaction, and then I'll just point back to the part about the current threats making cards and mana and using that to stop your opponents from doing that.

I would guess the win rate of Sultai Midrange in late-Core Set 2021 Standard was multiple percentage points lower on high ladder than in events with open decklists. I won a ton of games with four lands, Uro, and Extinction Event or whatever because I knew my opponent was attempting to play creatures and those six cards would do the trick. And if they were playing control I would just keep the Hydroid Krasis instead or keep the first seven with a bunch of Thought Erasure.


The only time we have really seen aggressive decks crack through in the last while is when they exploit a static metagame with threats that completely dodge the expected removal. Think of how Mono-Black Aggro and a Winota deck leaning on Orzhov color threats smashed through the Players' Tour Finals full of Aether Gusts and light on ways to kill Rotting Regisaur or a lot of small dorks with more toughness than power.

Again some of this is the threats making the smaller starting hand sizes not matter as much, but open decklists plus the London mulligan drastically reduces the viable angles of attack and forces people down the road of mirror matches.

I think you can maybe justify one without the other, but together it's a non-starter. I don't think you can move away from open deck lists if Twitch streaming of events is going to be something you want, but maybe with MDFC spell-lands balancing mana screw and mana flood, we can change the other one.


The Arena Economy


This might be a bit of yet another full post, but one of the bigger issues with the Arena economy is that it pushes players to not try things.


True story: Imagine you are me in early 2019. You see a Reddit post about Grixis Dragons at #53 on ladder or whatever. You want to try it, so you spend four rare wild cards on Dragon's Hoard. It is trash, you learn your lesson, and you go to build your next deck.

You can't spend rare wild cards on Tithe Taker because you spent them on Dragon's Hoards, also because you aren't literally a dragon with a hoard of gold wild cards. You can't ever really use those Dragon's Hoard again because you don't plan on playing some casual nonsense. You can't get those Dragon's Hoard, probably a desireable casual card, to someone who wants them in exchange for goods, services or Tithe Takers.

Aside: It is also kinda depressing to realize the most exciting card you can open from a booster on Arena isn't any specific card, but a blank artless wild card of the right rarity. If you want any assurance of the future of paper Maigc, the concept of a chase rare that people crack packs for is dead on Arena and they keep printing those cards anyways.

The story has two happy endings: I realized my Venerated Loxodon deck was better if I put commons that cost one-mana in it instead of rares that cost two-mana, and I just played the best deck more from there on out. I'm no tangrams, but I certainly have had my fair share of success on the SCGTour Online forcing people to beat my Uros instead of not doing it and I owe it partly to Dragon's Hoard being a garbage competitive card.

And that's me, who has seen time and time again at the highest levels of the game that you learn from trying things and has been rewarded for doing so.

Imagine someone just trying to get into the game now. They get beaten by Four-Color Omnath. They feel sad they lose to it. They build it, they learn to Four-Color Omnath people, and the cycle continues. Or they don't and they stop playing.

I also literally have no idea how to get into a match on Arena in an enviroment where Four-Color Omnath isn't a likely deck my opponent is playing. You can't post “No LD No Counters” and find and opponent. You probably can't even wait for a Brawl opponent, probably not even Historic (also good joke entering Historic if you care about wild cards at the recent rate of releases), and is there another format. Maybe there's like a No Omnath Direct Challenge Discord I don't know about.

The end result is the experience of bashing your head into Four-Color Omnath and quitting or playing it being the simplest options on a lot of levels becomes universal. When Kaladesh Standard got bad I just played Modern for a year.

I don't think that things would be all sunshine and daisies if Arena didn't push Standard this way. Oko and Field of the Dead were paper issues back when we could do things like travel to the basement of the Valley Forge Casino and Resort. But if you want to look at things that changed the tone of the discussion, this is a big one.

I don't think a complete overhaul of the Arena economy is without major other considerations, a good idea, or even doable, but breaking the ways it promotes Standard Tier 0 mono-cultures is necessary to the continuing health of the game.


It isn't just one thing that broke Standard. Just like it wasn't just one card that needed to be banned. A lot of systems broke down the line. Some of them easy to fix, some a bit hard, and some you probably just have to live with. It's possible to build a functional format from the disaster we play in right now, but it will take a few steps. Bans of Uro, Omnath, Lucky Clover, Embercleave, Scute Swarm, whatever are just scraping the surface a temporary patch.